Willian Damon and Howard Gardner at the Inaugural Conference on Formative Education.
Centering a Movement
Whole-person education is on the rise. BC’s Transformative Education Lab is helping define what that means.
There has been a lot of discussion of late about a return to whole-person education. Sometimes referred to as formative education, holistic education, or even character education, these various pedagogies adhere to the personal formation of students across multiple dimensions. To the academics who teach these various methods, the distinctions among them matter but perhaps less so than the fact that they are all coming into renewed focus as major objectives in higher education today.

In early October, at Boston College, a group of empirical researchers, educational philosophers, and practitioners associated with these methods came together to explore how their work aligns and diverges when it comes to teaching to the whole person. The Inaugural Conference on Formative Education was hosted by the Transformative Education Lab at BC, a newly launched hub for research on holistic, formative human development focused on K–16 education. The lab is led by director Deoksoon Kim and is housed in the Lynch School of Education and Human Development, led by Dean Stanton Wortham.
The two dozen or so participants in the conference spent two days together in small and large groups considering questions such as: is formative education, once the bedrock of higher education, more critical than ever? If so, what does it look like, and how can the various advocates of this method move it forward, without stepping on one another’s good intentions?
A primary motivation for the conference was the growing question of how colleges and universities can attend to the human qualities of their students, including how they develop along multiple, simultaneous dimensions. Theories as to what is driving this interest include emotional and behavioral health problems among students brought on by the pandemic, excessive social media, and a global reckoning in the age of AI about what it means to be human. A key ingredient in this thinking is how to help students live lives of purpose and meaning beyond just their chosen professions and skills. This approach challenges the decades-long trend towards narrower academic goals and post-graduate economic metrics.
This movement of the needle—if not full pendulum swing—towards a broader view of student success is a welcome change for the many advocates from diverse institutions and disciplines who are working in this area, but it is not without challenges. In his introduction to a public conversation among four experts at the conference, Dean Wortham said, “You have lots of people trying to devise a curriculum or program or philosophy or approach within this larger space of flourishing, wellbeing, character education, growth mindset, positive education, and so forth. It’s not clear how they relate to one another.”
The presentation that followed was a synchronous case in point. The first two speakers, William Damon and Howard Gardner, are giants in their fields, as well as long-time colleagues and friends. Damon, a professor emeritus at Stanford University, is the country’s preeminent scholar on purpose, having defined it as the need for a “beyond the self” element.
“Purpose, meaning, and fulfillment have been incredibly complicated by technology." –Howard Gardner
In his remarks, Damon said, “One of the pillars of formative education is purpose. Purpose has to be meaningful, but that’s not all. In a personal sense, it gives people a commitment that adds energy, joy, and fulfillment in life, but it also pre-empts self-absorption, which any expert knows is a risk.”
Gardner is one of the most influential educational psychologists of the past half-century. His GoodWork Project at Harvard, which was co-created with Damon, helped advance contemporary thinking about ethics, character, and professional responsibility.
Gardner reiterated Damon’s point with a reference to AI. “Purpose, meaning, and fulfillment have been incredibly complicated by technology,” he said. “I think the best we can do with our students is to help them realize [this] complexity—and hope they will use their sense of purpose in the right direction.”
Also on the panel was Suzanne Shanahan, the executive director of the Institute for Social Concerns at the University of Notre Dame. She framed the goal of her formative work as “shared human flourishing.”
“For me, the essence of what formative education can be is about transcendence,” she said. “It’s about the liberation and the possibility that come for us both as individuals, and as a society, to share something extraordinary.”
The fourth panelist, Oon Seng Tan, a professor at the National Institute of Education in Singapore, brought a cultural perspective to the formation conversation. “Education in Singapore has always been about social harmony and nation building,” he said. “The goals of formative education are, number one, to be a good person and number two, to be a contributing citizen. A good person relates to character. A contributing citizen relates to competence.”
In examining these and other methods of formative education, Wortham and Kim see the field’s “big tent” as a good thing and are pleased with the outcomes of the conference. “Participants converged on the view that formative education matters because it rests on a shared commitment to human dignity and flourishing—one that holds across a thick pluralism of backgrounds, faith traditions, and school settings,” Kim said. “They agreed that it counters purely transactional views of schooling by helping students move from ‘I’ to ‘we,’ and that formation is lifelong and relational, nurtured through reflection and supportive environments within a broader infrastructure, rather than isolated programs.”
They consider the conference the beginning of a continued conversation about how multiple methods of formative education can align to advance a new movement. Kim said confronting challenges—such as how not to frame the intrinsic-motivation elements of formative education as at odds with extrinsic goals such as financial security—will be important. And they are explicit in the fact that Boston College is well positioned to lead the way.
“This is an institution that's been trying to do holistic approaches to education and human development since its founding,” Wortham said. “We've been trying to figure out how to help people work toward lives of purpose, a sense of their calling, a sense of what their connection is to a larger moral order—and push it forward to advance the common good. We are in the fortunate position of never having made the mistake of ignoring all [of] that in the first place.”
You can reach LearningWell Editor Marjorie Malpiede at mmalpiede@learningwellmag.org with comments, ideas, or tips.